Almost 100 readers chimed in with their choices.
In the comments, readers wrote about their love for the downtown ice cream parlor.
Reader Sadie Beeden said Woody's had won a place in her heart.
"Woody's is the best. Was a customer of his way back when he was at his original location next to Carlos O'Kelly's. Also enjoyed the wonderful, generous annual picnics he used to provide the community free of charge as a way of saying "thank you" for our business. I wish him much success at his new location in the City.
Complete final results: